• Home
  • About FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Award Winning Team
  • Advertise
  • Student Writers
  • Cookbook
  • 507-765-2151

Fillmore County Journal

"Where Fillmore County News Comes First"

  • News
    • Feature
    • Agriculture
    • Arts & Culture
    • Business
    • Education
    • Faith & Worship
    • Government
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Outdoors
  • Sports
  • Schools
    • Caledonia Warriors
    • Chatfield Gophers
    • Fillmore Central Falcons
    • Grand Meadow Super Larks
    • Houston Hurricanes
    • Kingsland Knights
    • Lanesboro Burros
    • LeRoy-Ostrander Cardinals
    • Mabel-Canton Cougars
    • Rushford-Peterson Trojans
    • Spring Grove Lions
  • Columnists
  • Commentary
  • Obituaries
  • Police/Court
  • Legal Notices
  • Veterans
    • Fillmore County Veterans
    • Houston & Mower County Veterans
  • Professional Directory
    • Ask the Experts

Letter about climate change

August 5, 2019 by Fillmore County Journal

Fillmore County Journal - Weekly Newspaper Serving Southeast Minnesota's Bluff Country - Letter to the Editor

To the Editor,

In “The Professor forgot to tell us something,” (FCJ, Monday, July 8, 2019) Col. Stan Gudmundson resorts to an old rhetorical trick: If you don’t have the facts on your side, attack the source. The facts are these: the Earth is getting warmer, and emissions of carbon dioxide caused by human activities are the major cause. The article that Jeff Erding cited was indeed published in 1922, but it has little to do with whether or not global climate change is caused by human activities. As I stated in my previous letter, “Every single one of the facts Erding states is blatantly false or misleading.”

Properly understood, science does not depend on politics or religion. Through a tenuous and convoluted causal chain, Gudmundson connects my claim to George Soros, the boogieman of all conservatives. First of all, the source I cited was snopes.com, not IFCN, and snopes.com is a recognized credible source for debunking false claims. Even if George Soros funds the Poynter Institute, and the Poynter Institute funds IFCN, none of this has anything to do with climate change. The earth simply doesn’t care if George Soros funds the Poynter Institute.

The Earth is getting warmer. This is true whether Col. Gudmundson, Jeff Erding, or I believe it or not. We are in an existential crisis because of the effects of climate change, and it is necessary for people of all faiths and political opinions to band together to mitigate its effects. 

Kim A. Stelson

College of Science and 

Engineering Distinguished 

Professor

University of Minnesota

Minneapolis and Lanesboro, Minn. 

Filed Under: Commentary Tagged With: Letter to the Editor

Comments

  1. Aaron Bishop says

    August 6, 2019 at 5:42 pm

    Greetings Kim,

    I would emphasize that the 1922 article was published, but the last claim Erding attributed to the article was fabricated. The fabricated quote by Erding who attributed it to the 1922 article was: ‘If the warming trend continues, many coastal cities worldwide will be uninhabitable’.

    I addressed this in my Climate Change Mythconceptions Pt. 2

    http://fillmorecountyjournal.com/devils-advocate-climate-change-mythconceptions-pt-2/

    Cheers

Weather

FILLMORE COUNTY WEATHER

Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota
Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota

NEWS

  • Features
  • Agriculture
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business
  • Education
  • Faith & Worship
  • Government
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Outdoors

More FCJ

  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions
  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions

© 2026 · Website Design and Hosting by SMG Web Design of Preston, MN.