• Home
  • About FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Award Winning Team
  • Advertise
  • Student Writers
  • Cookbook
  • 507-765-2151

Fillmore County Journal

"Where Fillmore County News Comes First"

  • News
    • Feature
    • Agriculture
    • Arts & Culture
    • Business
    • Education
    • Faith & Worship
    • Government
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Outdoors
    • Press Release
  • Sports
  • Schools
    • Caledonia Warriors
    • Chatfield Gophers
    • Fillmore Central Falcons
    • Grand Meadow Super Larks
    • Houston Hurricanes
    • Kingsland Knights
    • Lanesboro Burros
    • LeRoy-Ostrander Cardinals
    • Mabel-Canton Cougars
    • Rushford-Peterson Trojans
    • Spring Grove Lions
  • Columnists
  • Commentary
  • Obituaries
  • Police/Court
  • Legal Notices
  • Veterans
    • Fillmore County Veterans
    • Houston & Mower County Veterans
  • Professional Directory
    • Ask the Experts

Thyme & Again – Past and Present Pie

November 16, 2026 by SMG Web Design Leave a Comment

By Angela Denstad

Time and again, as the weather cools and the world starts to look a little starker, the trees increasingly bare, we return to the tastes of home — to simple flavors that comfort and nourish in ways beyond just filling our bellies. I imagine this is a yearning early New England colonists knew well. For all their flaws, and make no mistake, they were colonizers — claiming land that was already occupied, exploiting resources, and forcing assimilation of Indigenous people—they were also human. And they were trying to survive a harsh climate for which they were unprepared. So when it came time for them to count their blessings and give thanks for their harvest, what was on their table?

Unsurprisingly, few early settler colonists found time to write their food memoires or photograph their plates. But fast-forward to the early 1800s and we do have a vivid portrait of life as recalled by Edward Everet Hale in his book A New England Boyhood. Here’s how he described his family Thanksgiving experiences:

“This was one of the marvels to us children, that it was possible to be at dinner two hours. There was no desire to slip down from the chair and go off to play … You began with your chicken pie and your roast turkey. You ate as much as you could, and you then ate what you could of mince pie, squash pie, Marlborough pie, cranberry tart, and plum pudding.”

So, clearly pies were prized comfort food then, as they still are today. But Marlborough pie? What’s that?

This all-but-forgotten New England staple came, unsurprisingly, from England and, aside from its homey appeal, it was a treasured recipe for making the most of fruit that was about to spoil. Soft apples worked best here, melting into the custard. The sweet apples were balanced by lemon, and those who could would add exotic flavorings like nutmeg and Spanish sherry. Marlborough pie is a slice of history still served up at Sturbridge Village, the living history museum located in central Massachusetts.

So why did it fall off the Thanksgiving menu? Some cite the improvement of food storage and refrigeration that kept apples fresher longer, so there was no need to quickly use up old fruit. Similar, I suppose, to how I only think of baking banana bread when I have overripe fruit on my counter; I wouldn’t go buy fresh bananas and wait for them to turn. Others correctly point out the amount of effort required, and I can sympathize with a busy Thanksgiving host not wanting the extra fuss of cooking the apple filling. Still, if you’re interested in a taste of history, on Thanksgiving or any other, or you want to bring a thoughtful contribution to a potluck style meal, it’s worth considering this recipe for an historical treat.

Fully enjoy this past favorite, being present with all your senses, and give thanks for our many blessings as we begin a full season of giving.

 

 

Marlborough Pie

1 prepared 9-inch pastry shell, preferably homemade in a deep

   pie plate

2 pounds apples, peeled

½ cup sugar

2 tablespoons freshly squeezed lemon juice

2 tablespoons dry sherry (optional)

4 tablespoons butter

3 large eggs, lightly beaten

1 cup heavy cream

1 teaspoon ground cinnamon

¼ teaspoon freshly grated nutmeg

Preheat the oven to 400 degrees with a rack positioned in the middle. For a crisper crust, place a baking stone on the rack to preheat.

Set a box grater in a large bowl and, using the large holes, grate the apples down to their cores. Sprinkle the grated apple with sugar, lemon juice, and sherry, if using.

In a large nonstick skillet, melt the butter, then add the grated apple mixture and cook, stirring until the liquid begins to boil. Reduce the heat to low and continue cooking, stirring occasionally, until the apples are tender and most of the liquid has evaporated, about 15 minutes. Remove from the heat and let cool at least 10 minutes.

In a large bowl, whisk eggs, cream, cinnamon, and nutmeg together. Stir in the cooled apples until thoroughly combined. Pour the custard into the crust, set the pie plate on a rimmed baking sheet, and transfer to the oven. Bake for 15 minutes at 400, then reduce the heat to 350 degrees and continue baking until the custard is barely set and lightly puffed, about 35-45 minutes. Allow to cool fully before slicing. Serve chilled or at room temperature.

Filed Under: Columnists, Food & Dining, Social Scenes

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Weather

FILLMORE COUNTY WEATHER

Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota
Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota
Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota

NEWS

  • Features
  • Agriculture
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business
  • Education
  • Faith & Worship
  • Government
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Outdoors

More FCJ

  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions
  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions

© 2026 · Website Design and Hosting by SMG Web Design of Preston, MN.