By Karen Reisner
At the November 10 meeting of the county board, Public Health Director Jessica Erickson said the current Tobacco Ordinance was written and approved in 1997. Several state and federal regulations have changed since then. Health-based decisions are driving the proposed updates to the ordinance.
The greatest issue driving the discussion this day is an attempt to reduce the risk of youth becoming addicted to tobacco products. Youth are drawn to flavored tobacco products. There has been a program to educate children about addiction in five of the six school districts.
The importance of this issue was demonstrated by the size of the crowd present for the public hearing. Nineteen people addressed the board on the sale of flavored products in Fillmore County. Another 14 opinions that had been submitted through a letter were read aloud. Twenty-four responses wanted the updated ordinance approved or even strengthened.
Each person was given a maximum of three minutes to speak. Several felt the proposed changes did not go far enough because it still allowed mint, menthol and wintergreen flavoring.
Those against the ordinance that banned the sale in the county of most flavored products (fruit and candy flavors) were retailers or in support of retailers. They argued it would be a significant loss of business. Youth will still manage to obtain flavored products out of the county or online where the market is unregulated with age protocols. This ordinance will punish compliant businessmen. Philip Morris International U.S. argued that these products help adult smokers to shift to smoke-free nicotine products, less harmful products with a lower risk for disease.
Many that were in support of banning the sale of fruit- and candy-flavored products brought attention to the damage nicotine and tobacco does to young people. The county provided data on the effect of flavored nicotine on youth health. Damages from nicotine and tobacco include, but are not limited to, stiffening of blood vessels, increased risk of asthma and other breathing issues, mouth and gum damage, cancer and alteration of brain pathways for learning and self-control. Nicotine use for young people can lead to long-term nicotine addiction.
Nearly 90% of teens who vape use flavored vapes. Nearly 91% of teens who are pouch users use flavored products. It was recognized that the ban could financially harm vaping and tobacco specialty shops, but the ban is expected to have a minimal financial affect on convenience stores and gas stations.
Those in favor of banning most flavored products included a pastor, an area school principal, a retired RN, a school psychologist, a retired lawyer who worked on the tobacco settlement, a Zumbro Valley Health Center representative, nurse practitioner, representative for the American Heart Association, ADH Advocate, African American Tobacco Control Leadership Council representative, Association of Non-Smokers, Parents Against Vaping and a retired physician. Individuals related stories about family members who struggled with nicotine addiction. A former drug user said “nicotine is extremely addictive.” Another said there are “no positive health benefits.”
Commissioner Mitch Lentz felt it would be easier to ban all flavors, rather than to allow mint, menthol and wintergreen. Chairman Randy Dahl said any amendments at this point can only be minor changes. It was decided this would be a major change to the proposed updates to the ordinance and would therefore require another public hearing.
Commissioner Duane Bakke said the proposed ordinance had good changes; he was fine with the exemptions for mint, menthol and wintergreen. There already are restrictions on youth purchasing these products. He recommended approval of the amended ordinance as presented.
Commissioner Marc Prestby called it a working document; he said he had sympathy for the retailers, but youth getting access to these products is a big problem. Lentz added he will support the proposed amended language, adding they may have to improve it.
The updated Tobacco Ordinance was approved unanimously as presented.
Other Business in Brief
• A bid from Minnowa Construction in the amount of $253,300 was accepted for a bridge replacement project on CR 105 in Arendahl Township;
• A bid from Minnowa Construction in the amount of $271,953 was accepted for a bridge replacement project north of Peterson on CSAH 25;
• A bid from Minnowa Construction in the amount of $609,423 was accepted for three box bridges in Preble, Canton and Fountain Townships;
• Rochester Sand & Gravel was awarded a full depth reclamations and bituminous paving project with a bid in the amount of $1,894,588;
• The 2027 21.5-mile seal coat project was awarded to Scott Construction with a bid of $691,571;
• A concrete overlay project on 6.5 miles of CR 12 was awarded to Croell, Inc., with a bid in the amount of $3,671,073;
• The resignation of Adam Sveen, Highway Maintenance Specialist, was accepted effective November 12. Approval was given to select an additional candidate from an existing interview pool for a replacement;
• Approval was granted to advertise for a replacement Human Services Director.
• Approval was granted for the 2027 Community and Economic Development Associates 2027 contract for services in the amount of $52,739 (a 3% increase);
• A Memorandum of Understanding between Fillmore County and the state to upgrade the audio and video system in the main Courtroom was approved. The state will be solely responsible for the project costs ($138,820 grant).
• Two candidates had signed up at this time to run for the District 3 vacancy. An election is scheduled for February 9, 2027.


Leave a Reply