• Home
  • About FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Award Winning Team
  • Advertise
  • Student Writers
  • Cookbook
  • 507-765-2151

Fillmore County Journal

"Where Fillmore County News Comes First"

  • News
    • Feature
    • Agriculture
    • Arts & Culture
    • Business
    • Education
    • Faith & Worship
    • Government
    • Health & Wellness
    • Home & Garden
    • Outdoors
    • Press Release
  • Sports
  • Schools
    • Caledonia Warriors
    • Chatfield Gophers
    • Fillmore Central Falcons
    • Grand Meadow Super Larks
    • Houston Hurricanes
    • Kingsland Knights
    • Lanesboro Burros
    • LeRoy-Ostrander Cardinals
    • Mabel-Canton Cougars
    • Rushford-Peterson Trojans
    • Spring Grove Lions
  • Columnists
  • Commentary
  • Obituaries
  • Police/Court
  • Legal Notices
  • Veterans
    • Fillmore County Veterans
    • Houston & Mower County Veterans
  • Professional Directory
    • Ask the Experts

County Attorneys Oppose Minnesota Sentencing Guidelines Proposal

November 16, 2026 by Karen Reisner Leave a Comment

The Minnesota Sentencing Guidelines Commission (MSGC) is a 13-member commission tasked with developing uniform and fair standards for use by district court judges for sentencing in felony cases. Most members are appointed by the governor; judiciary and court related members are appointed by the Chief Justice of the Minnesota Supreme Court.

The MSGC has proposed sentencing guideline modifications to the legislature, which has led to some opposition by the Minnesota County Attorneys Association (MCAA), a not-for-profit corporation dedicated to the improvement of justice in the state, and Third Judicial District County Attorneys.

The proposed modifications could take affect unless they are rejected by the legislature. The modifications could limit how multiple felony convictions around the same time are calculated into history points. This will likely result in shorter sentences for offenders with several convictions.

A 1981 Supreme Court case, State v. Hernandez, led to a practice that “allows a district court to sentence an offender for multiple offenses at one time,” adding criminal history points and sentencing each next offense with a new/higher criminal history score. The offender is sentenced based on criminal history points; when convicted of multiple felonies, an offender will have more criminal history points leading to a longer sentence. Simply put, the proposed modifications in sentencing guidelines will likely reduce sentences for repeat felony offenders when multiple case are considered on the same day.

The MSGC’s proposal will end the practice of “Hernandizing.” Criminal history points will not accrue for each pending offense. This will risk treating offenders facing multiple unrelated charges more leniently. County attorneys argue this will reward defendants that have multiple cases resolved together. The attorneys believe Hernandizing is a useful tool for prosecuting repeat offenders. County attorneys maintain if the practice of “Hernandizing” is not allowed, one of the most important aspects of the criminal justice system will be taken away: discretion.

County attorneys believe the proposed modification in sentencing guidelines could “negatively affect victims’ rights, public safety, and the integrity of the justice system.” They believe it doesn’t make sense to reduce sentences of repeat felony offenders. If these modifications are put into effect, offenders will get lesser penalties; they will not be held accountable appropriately.

Those in favor of the modifications argue they are considering the cumulative sentencing weight and racial sentencing disparities.

An op-ed was issued by the MCAA outlining the association’s reasons why getting rid of Hernandizing is not in the interest of public safety.

Fillmore County Attorney Brett Corson sees the proposed modifications as a “chipping away at public safety.” The elimination of Hernandizing means that “offenders being sentenced on the same day for multiple felony convictions will be treated like a first-time offender with one felony conviction.” This will be added to a change by the legislature that reduced a defendant’s probationary time from 10 or 15 years to five years. “Reducing the criminal history score significantly reduces the sentence that can be imposed by the court.” Corson believes we need to help people “get back on track,” but “if an individual continues to commit crimes, shouldn’t there be meaningful and effective consequences?”

Winona County Attorney Karin Sonneman strongly “supports the MCAA’s clearly laid out reasons why getting rid of Hernandizing is not in the best interests of public safety.” She strongly opposes the MSGC proposal. When asked if the loss of the discretion to use this tool will affect her office’s efforts to protect victim rights, protect the public, and the promotion of justice, she answered yes to all three. In answer to a question of how the proposed modifications will affect her office’s ability to prosecute offenders, Sonneman responded: “Removing the prosecutor’s ability to request Hernandized sentencing and in turn then, removing the Court’s ability to order a sentence under the Hernandized sentencing practice, would drastically discount the severity of a convicted defendant’s multiple criminal actions (a crime spree) at the expense of crime victims’ safety and confidence in the justice system, and public safety overall.”

Houston County Attorney Suzanne Bublitz said she does not agree with the MSGC recommendation to do away with the Hernandizing process. It is a very important prosecuting tool. She referred to the Minnesota County Attorneys Association op-ed outlining the reasons to keep the practice of Hernandiizing to determine an appropriate sentence for offenders convicted of multiple felonies. In the op-ed, the MCAA wrote directly to the public to inform the public.

Judge Jeremy Clinefelter explained it is currently common “to have a defendant sentenced for multiple files that have accumulated over time or for multiple offenses in the same file that are not part of a single behavioral incident.” He went on to describe exceptions to the rule. He suggested that the proposed modifications are a complicated public policy debate. As a judge, he is obligated to remain neutral or impartial. “I take no position on it.” He continues, however, it could be a significant change on a method that has been used to calculate criminal history scores for decades. It will not affect a judge’s discretion; “the only discretion of the judge at sentencing is sentencing within the box range provided by the sentencing guidelines.” Guidelines are the law on sentencing. Hernandizing is not optional or discretionary now, and if it is modified in some form, that will not be optional or discretionary either.

The MSGC met on November 5 to work on finalizing the proposed modifications to the guidelines.

A public hearing is tentatively scheduled to be held on December 10 on the proposed modifications of the sentencing guidelines. MSGC email: sentencing.guidelines@state.mn.us

Filed Under: Feature, Police Reports

About Karen Reisner

Reporter
karen@fillmorecountyjournal.com

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Weather

FILLMORE COUNTY WEATHER

Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota
Fillmore County Journal - Your number one source for news and community information in Fillmore County Minnesota

NEWS

  • Features
  • Agriculture
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business
  • Education
  • Faith & Worship
  • Government
  • Health & Wellness
  • Home & Garden
  • Outdoors

More FCJ

  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions
  • Home
  • About FCJ
  • Contact FCJ
  • FCJ Staff
  • Employment
  • Advertise
  • Commentary Policies & Submissions

© 2026 · Website Design and Hosting by SMG Web Design of Preston, MN.